Is there any scope for considering if it is meaningful to talk of a person tithing his intangible resources too?
Some intangible assets may be quite suitable for tithing. An
obvious example is one’s spare time. If you have, say, ten hours’ free and
disposable time each week, you metaphorically tithe it by setting one hour
aside and donating it for the benefit of others rather than indulging in an
enjoyable pastime of your own choice. Other intangible assets may be less
suitable, such as one’s intelligence, affection, patience or imagination. Some
assets are both tangible and intangible: money has a physical format when it is
represented by banknotes and coins, but for most people in the developed world
it is intangible, being represented by electronically transferable debt and
credit. The tithing of money is effectively required by the mitzvah of tzedakah
(loosely translated as “charity” though the word’s Hebrew root has strong
undertones of “justice” and “righteousness”): this is the setting aside of one
tenth of one’s income for distribution to those who need it. Tzedakah gets
several honorable mentions in Avot and, while
Rabbi Akiva does not list it in 3:17 among his “fences,” other rabbis do: Hillel
teaches (Avot 2:8) that it is a sort of fence to peace in that, the more tzedakah one
gives, the greater is the amount of peace in the world and, if tzedakah falls within the general
category of “good deeds,” it also acts as a shield against divine
retribution.
It cannot be said that the tithing of intangibles is what
Rabbi Akiva had in mind. However, the overall principle is equally applicable
to all assets, material and immaterial: if you give part of what you have and
dedicate it to the benefit of others, should you not be entitled to expect not just God’s
outline approval but a measure of assistance in maximising the benefit you
derive from what you retain?